When she was only fifteen, Elizabeth Lerner was kidnapped for almost six weeks by Walter Bowman, a young man whom she caught in a state park land near a creek, burying the body of his latest victim. Walter decided not kill Elizabeth in that moment, and drove along the highway with her in tow, pretending they were siblings. Elizabeth, a pliable girl at home, learned to live with the man, ultimately deciding to endure whatever happened in order to stay alive.
Twenty two years after those events, already married and with two children of her own, after living in England for several years, Elizabeth Lerner, now Eliza Benedict, comes back to live in Maryland, where she receives a letter from her former captor. Walter, now in death row for the rape and murder of two other teenage girls, has seen a photograph of her at a social function and recognizes her immediately. The dreaded phrase “I’d know you anywhere” leaves her breathless. Those long gone painful days that her mind has suppressed rush to the surface and this time she has to confront them.
This story had so many possibilities…It was a great premise that, in my opinion, didn’t quite deliver. The author spent too much time humanizing both victim and captor, and everyone in between. Another thing that I didn’t like about this book was that several characters had different stances toward the death penalty, as if the author had not been brave enough to venture her opinion for fear of alienating her readers.