Snapshots - #30: Megan Leavey, The Beguiled, and Lady Macbeth


The movies…

Megan Leavey (♦♦♦♦): Young marine corporal Megan Leavey (Kate Mara) is assigned, as a result of a disciplinary action, the task of cleaning the corps' kennels for one week. She instantly takes a liking for the dogs, passing all her exams with flying colors to be given the opportunity of being a dog handler.
When Rex, an aggressive German shepherd, bites and breaks his handler's hand, he is reassigned to Leavey. Soon they are both training to sniff out IED explosives, while they work on bonding, and are deployed to Iraq. Over the course of 100 missions, as a team they save countless lives, but both get injured in the line of duty. Leavey is evacuated and granted leave; Rex stays behind. After many attempts to reunite and Leavey's efforts to keep him, the army retires him and she adopts him. Together they live until the end of his days.
I'm a big sucker for animal stories, even more so if they are well acted, thus it's no coincidence that I liked Megan Leavey a great deal. Add to that that it is based on a true story—both subjects war heroes who saved countless lives as a team over 100 missions in six months during the Iraq War—, with credible, edge-of-your-seat war action, a sentimental journey to adopt the dog...They had me at hello. Needless to say, I cried too.
The Beguiled (2017), (♦♦♦): Virginia, 1864. It's three years into the U.S. Civil War. In the countryside a former mansion has been repurposed as a seminary for young ladies. Only five students, a teacher, and the headmistress remain; some of them have families on the outside, but are better off at school.
Picking mushroom around the property, a young student finds a wounded Yankee corporal (Colin Farrell) and brings him to school. He is tended to and allowed to heal, while each woman vie for the soldier's attention in her own way. Little do they know that those whispered sweet nothings will alter the course of their lives in ways they could have not imagined.
Written, directed, and produced in part by Sofia Coppola, The Beguiled is a Civil War period drama that focuses on the emotional needs of women during a conflagration. The need to show a little vanity, guarded reserve and strength, for their outward beauties to be noticed and praised, and most of all, the need to band together to protect one another of the potential bestiality of the world at large.
The Beguiled is an accomplished movie that starts with inane domestic scenes punctuated by giggling, bird calls, and occasional distant cannon blasts, and soon takes a dark turn when an unexpected accident is questionably handled. From that point forward, the plot evolves into slow simmering suspense, while at the notes of atmospheric music, one wonders if what happened after the accident was done with evil intent, and if the events that ensued could have been different. The answer in those cases is no, which is what makes this little film, acted mostly by women (Nicole Kidman, Kirsten Dunst, Elle Fanning), so haunting.
Lady Macbeth (♦♦♦): England, 1865. Young Katherine (Florence Pugh) has been sold to marriage into a stifling, rich family. Her husband pays no attention to her, while her father-in-law scolds her constantly. When both men leave her to care for the estate while they travel on business, she meets a fiery, newly arrived young groom. For him she will go to lengths she never thought possible.
It was not that Lady Macbeth was a bad movie, or that Florence Pugh didn't give a good enough performance as leading lady; I was just not impressed with this film, an adaptation of the novel of the same title, mainly because of the "Thèrése Raquin vibe" that I could not shake off. Because of that, I found it entirely predictable and couldn't help but compare it, while it was running, to 2013's In Secret, starring Elizabeth Olsen, Oscar Isaac, and Jessica Lange, a solid, if still mediocre, adaptation of Thèrése Raquin that I watched last year.
In Secret has more likable protagonists, better chemistry by the whole ensemble cast, and a more empathetic approach to the plot. The ending is also more fitting than Lady Macbeth's. You'll probably say that they are two different novels, but the plot is very similar, hence my frustration with Lady Macbeth.

Comments

  1. I'm a fool for animal movies too, so of course I rented Megan Leavey and liked it quite a bit too. I had a German Shepard dog after college and she was wonderful, like the dog in the movie is. Kate Mara is quite good too in the film, I keep thinking of her role in House of Cards. I only watched like one or two seasons of it. The other two films I have not seen, should I skip? hmm

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Rex, the German shepherd in the movie, was beautiful, so I bet your dog was too. I recommend The Beguiled (2017) more than I do Lady Macbeth. Both have excellent performances but aren't more than mediocre. I'm glad I saw them though, but you decide whether to skip. If you want to choose one, watch The Beguiled. It made quite an impression on me.

      Delete
  2. I will be seeing all of these. I looked up Therese Raquin and there appear to be two movies, one from 1953 and one from 2013. Have you seen both?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I only saw the 2013 one. Good to know though; I'll look for the other one.

      Delete
  3. As always, an excellent series of reviews. I don't watch that many movies, but Megan Leavey sure sounds like a winner.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks, Dorothy! Being the nature lover that you are, I think you would enjoy Megan Leavey.

      Delete
  4. I definitely fancy the dog film - Megan Leavey. Funnily enough one of my recent reads (Dogs of War - a work of fiction about part dog/part human fighting machines) - the main character was Rex. I'm sure I've seen an old version of the Beguiled with Clint Eastwood (although I'm not sure if it was the same name - but the plot definitely seems to read the same). I'll have to check this one out and see how they compare.
    Lynn :D

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I recommend the dog film ( :-)) and what a coincidence that the dog in the book was also named Rex. I think the stars are trying to tell you something. ;-) Yes, you are right; there is one Beguiled with Clint Eastwood (the original). This latest Beguiled is a remake. I have the other on my wishlist to compare, as you suggest.

      Delete
  5. Huh, I didn't think to draw a comparison between In Secret and Lady Macbeth but I really should have because I read the book In Secret is based on a couple years ago. I like Lady Macbeth more overall, but neither struck me as particularly memorable.

    I plan to see The Beguiled, though I don't think it's the sort of film I would usually watch if it weren't based on a book.

    I've heard great things about Megan Leavey, but decided not to watch it because I can't handle any kind of drama involving animals being hurt/separated from their human companions/etc. Too many feels! Especially since I don't have a dog right now. :(

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I was surprised that you didn't make the connection because I've seen you talking about Therese Raquin, but I only made the connection because I saw In Secret last year instead of in 2013. While both are unremarkable, I think In Secret is superior for several reasons, and it has stayed with me longest.

      The Beguiled is a slow burning film, the artsy but not that popular kind, but quite effective if you ask me.

      I think you would like Megan Leavey. You probably remember that I recommended A Dog's Purpose and you didn't like it much; well, Megan Leavey is not sugary at all, though I may be biased. And it ends on a positive note despite the previous drama; I would say it is less about the drama of being apart than it is a journey to be reunited. That's what I loved most about it.

      Delete

Post a Comment

Kindly leave your comments and suggestions.

Popular posts from this blog

El Reino de Este Mundo by Alejo Carpentier (♦♦♦♦)

After Acts by Bryan Litfin (♦♦♦♦♦)

Snapshots - #20: Westworld, The Young Pope, and more…